CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

RE: CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

Kenneth — Mon, 27 Apr 2020 09:15:31 GMT

It's been a while since I looked at this.

Do you have an on-air sniffer log? Is there any difference if you are using TSPX_security_enabled (presuming bonding is supported)?

Is it the same if you are using the default SDK example? For example:
https://infocenter.nordicsemi.com/topic/com.nordic.infocenter.sdk5.v15.2.0/ble_sdk_app_csc.html

I notice the disconnect reason is HCI_CONNECTION_TIMEOUT, this may be caused by an assert (fault_handler()), have you checked that?

RE: CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

cavalihno — Fri, 24 Apr 2020 16:01:52 GMT

I have also problem with pass this test CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C

At the step 5 of this precedure, you can find that "the Lower Tester does not send any Confirmation to acknowledge this indication".

After that IUT sent:

+18236 ms
Receive Event:           L2CAP?L2CAP_LE_CONNECTION_UPDATE_IND{
                           peerAddr=0xCC52D3B4B51F,
                           peerAddrType=HCI_LE_RANDOM_DEVICE_ADDRESS,
                           minInterval=0x0014,
                           maxInterval=0x0028,
                           slaveLatency=0x0000,
                           supervision_timeout=0x01F4
                         }


+18236 ms
Send Event:              L2CAP!L2CA_LE_CONNECTION_UPDATE_RSP{
                           peerAddr=0xCC52D3B4B51F,
                           peerAddrType=0x01,
                           paramAccepted=1
                         }

and next:

+40544 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_DISCONNECT_IND{
                           lcid=0x1205
                         }


+40544 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_LE_DISCONNECTION_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK,
                           connectionHandle=0x0063,
                           reason=HCI_CONNECTION_TIMEOUT
                         }


+40544 ms
Verdict Description:     Unexpected ATT Disconnect received.

What sould I do in situation when Lower Tester does not send any Confirmation to acknowledge this indication? As Kiyoshi said it is abnormal situation.

I will be grateful for help.

Full log here:

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<ARCHIVE>
  <VERSION>2.0</VERSION>
  <PicsPixit>Test Case Started: CPS v. 7.6.0.15, CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C started on Friday, April 24, 2020, 10:37:18

ICS VALUES:

TSPC_ALL FALSE
TSPC_CPS_0_1 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_0_2 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_0a_1 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_1_1 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_1_2 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_2_1 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_2 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_2_3 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_4 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_2_5 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_6 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_7 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_8 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_9 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_10 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_2_11 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_12 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_13 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_14 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_15 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_16 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_17 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_18 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_2_19 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_20 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_21 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_22 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_23 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_2_24 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_3_1 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_3_2 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_3_3 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_3_4 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_3_5 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_6 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_3_7 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_8 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_3_9 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_10 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_11 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_12 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_13 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_14 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_15 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_16 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_3_17 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_3_18 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_19 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_20 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_21 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_22 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_23 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_24 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_25 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_26 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_27 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_28 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_29 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_30 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_3_31 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_32 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_33 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_34 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_35 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_36 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_37 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_38 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3_39 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_3a_1 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_4_1 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_4_2 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_4_3 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_4_4 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_4_5 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_4_6 TRUE
TSPC_CPS_5_1 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_5_2 FALSE
TSPC_CPS_5_3 FALSE

IXIT VALUES:

TSPX_bd_addr_iut CC52D3B4B51F
TSPX_iut_device_name_in_adv_packet_for_random_address 
TSPX_time_guard 180000
TSPX_use_implicit_send TRUE
TSPX_tester_database_file C:\Program Files\Bluetooth SIG\Bluetooth PTS\Data\SIGDatabase\PTS_CPP_db.xml
TSPX_mtu_size 23
TSPX_secure_simple_pairing_pass_key_confirmation FALSE
TSPX_delete_link_key FALSE
TSPX_pin_code 0000
TSPX_use_dynamic_pin FALSE
TSPX_delete_ltk FALSE
TSPX_security_enabled FALSE
TSPX_iut_setup_att_over_br_edr FALSE
TSPX_run_as_tester2 FALSE
TSPX_iut_slowest_connection_interval_vector_notification 50
TSPX_tester_appearance 0000
</PicsPixit>
  <LOG>

+140 ms
Message:                 MindTree Stack Version - 016.004.000



+140 ms
Initialize Test Case:    Build date: Jan  7 2020, 19:20:07



+140 ms
Start Test Case:         CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C



+140 ms
Message:                   PTS Log started on Friday, April 24, 2020, 10:37:18



+140 ms
Message:                   PTS: v7.6.0 Build 15



+140 ms
Message:                   OS: Microsoft Windows NT 6.1.7601 Service Pack 1



+140 ms
Message:                   OS Name: Microsoft Windows 7 专业版 



+4165 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+4196 ms
Send Event:              HCI!HCI_RESET


+4321 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_RESET_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK
                         }


+4321 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+4321 ms
Send Event:              HCI!HCI_SET_EVENT_MASK{
                           eventMask=0x3FFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
                         }


+4321 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_SET_EVENT_MASK_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK
                         }


+4321 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+4321 ms
Send Event:              HCI!HCI_READ_LOCAL_VERSION_INFORMATION


+4321 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_READ_LOCAL_VERSION_INFORMATION_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK,
                           hciVersion=0x08,
                           hciRevision=0x30E8,
                           lmpVersion=0x08,
                           manufacturerName=0x000A,
                           lmpSubversion=0x30E8
                         }


+4321 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+4321 ms
Send Event:              HCI!HCI_READ_BD_ADDR


+4321 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_READ_BD_ADDR_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK,
                           bdAddress=0x001BDCF21BF2
                         }


+4321 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+4321 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+4336 ms
Send Event:              HCI!HCI_LE_LOCAL_SUPPORTED_FEATURES


+4336 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_LE_READ_LOCAL_SUPPORTED_FEATURES_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK,
                           leFeatures=0x000000000000001F
                         }


+4336 ms
Send Event:              HCI!HCI_LE_SET_EVENT_MASK{
                           leEventMask=0x000000000000003F
                         }


+4336 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_LE_SET_EVENT_MASK_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK
                         }


+4336 ms
Send Event:              HCI!HCI_WRITE_LE_HOST_SUPPORTED{
                           leSupportedHost=HCI_LE_SUPPORTED_HOST_ENABLED,
                           simultaneousLeHost=HCI_SIMULTANEOUS_LE_HOST_ENABLED
                         }


+4336 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_WRITE_LE_HOST_SUPPORTED_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK
                         }


+4336 ms
Send Event:              HCI!HCI_LE_ADD_DEVICE_TO_WHITE_LIST{
                           addressType=HCI_LE_PUBLIC_DEVICE_ADDRESS,
                           address=0xCC52D3B4B51F
                         }


+4336 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_LE_ADD_DEVICE_TO_WHITE_LIST_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK
                         }


+4336 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+4336 ms
Send Event:              HCI!HCI_LE_ADD_DEVICE_TO_WHITE_LIST{
                           addressType=HCI_LE_RANDOM_DEVICE_ADDRESS,
                           address=0xCC52D3B4B51F
                         }


+4336 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_LE_ADD_DEVICE_TO_WHITE_LIST_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK
                         }


+4336 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+4336 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+4336 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+4336 ms
Send Event:              HCI!HCI_LE_SET_SCAN_PARAMETERS{
                           leScanType=HCI_LE_ACTIVE_SCANNING,
                           leScanInterval=0x001E,
                           leScanWindow=0x001E,
                           ownAddressType=HCI_LE_PUBLIC_DEVICE_ADDRESS,
                           scanningFilterPolicy=HCI_LE_ACCEPT_WHITE_LIST_ADVERTISING_PACKETS
                         }


+4352 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_LE_SET_SCAN_PARAMETERS_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK
                         }


+4352 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+4352 ms
Send Event:              HCI!HCI_LE_SET_SCAN_ENABLE{
                           leScanEnable=HCI_LE_SCAN_ENABLE,
                           filterDuplicates=HCI_LE_DUPLICATE_FILTERING_DISABLE
                         }


+4352 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_LE_SET_SCAN_ENABLE_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK
                         }


+5569 ms
Send Event:              HCI!HCI_LE_SET_SCAN_ENABLE{
                           leScanEnable=HCI_LE_SCAN_DISABLE,
                           filterDuplicates=HCI_LE_DUPLICATE_FILTERING_DISABLE
                         }


+5584 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_LE_SET_SCAN_ENABLE_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK
                         }


+5584 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+5600 ms
Send Event:              HCI!HCI_LE_CREATE_CONNECTION{
                           peerAddr=0xCC52D3B4B51F,
                           peerAddrType=HCI_LE_RANDOM_DEVICE_ADDRESS,
                           ownAddrType=HCI_LE_PUBLIC_DEVICE_ADDRESS,
                           scanInterval=0x0020,
                           scanWindow=0x0012,
                           filterPolicy=0x00,
                           minConnInterval=0x0032,
                           maxConnInterval=0x0046,
                           latency=0x0000,
                           supervisionTimeout=0x07D0,
                           minCELength=0x0000,
                           maxCELength=0x0000
                         }


+5616 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_LE_CREATE_CONNECTION_STATUS_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK
                         }


+6411 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_CONNECT_IND{
                           bdAddr=0xCC52D3B4B51F,
                           peerAddrType=HCI_LE_RANDOM_DEVICE_ADDRESS,
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           status=0x0000
                         }


+6411 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+6411 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_LE_CONNECTION_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK,
                           connectionHandle=0x0063,
                           role=HCI_ROLE_MASTER,
                           peerAddressType=HCI_LE_RANDOM_DEVICE_ADDRESS,
                           peerAddress=CC52D3B4B51F,
                           connInterval=0x003C,
                           connLatency=0x0000,
                           supervisionTimeout=0x07D0,
                           clockAccuracy=HCI_LE_CLOCK_ACCURACY_500PPM
                         }


+6411 ms
Verdict Description:     Connection setup successfully.



+6411 ms
Pass:                    Tester successfully initiated connection.



+6411 ms
Verdict Description:     Tester successfully initiated connection.



+8424 ms
Verdict Description:     LE Security not initiated due to TSPX_security_enabled value.



+8424 ms
Send Event:              HCI!GET_CONNECTION_HANDLE{
                           addr=0xCC52D3B4B51F,
                           addr_type=0x01,
                           conn_handle=0x0063
                         }


+8424 ms
Send Event:              ATT!ATT_FIND_BY_TYPE_VALUE_REQ{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           startingHandle=0x0001,
                           endingHandle=0xFFFF,
                           attributeType=0x2800,
                           length=0x0002,
                           1818
                         }


+8642 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_FIND_BY_TYPE_VALUE_RSP{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           HandleRange={
                             				{
                               foundAttributeHandle=0x000E,
                               endFoundHandle=0x0018
					
                             }
                           }
                         }


+8782 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_FIND_BY_TYPE_VALUE_CFM{
                           lcid=1205,
                           result=0x0000,
                           errorHandle=0x0000,
                           HandleRanges={
                             				{
                               foundAttributeHandle=0x000E,
                               endFoundHandle=0x0018,
                               
					
                             }
                           }
                         }


+8782 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+8782 ms
Verdict Description:     Discover Primary Service by Service UUID Request completed successfully.



+8782 ms
Pass:                    The IUT successfully returned the UUID for Cycling Power



+8782 ms
Verdict Description:     The IUT successfully returned the UUID for Cycling Power



+8782 ms
Send Event:              ATT!ATT_READ_BY_TYPE_REQ{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           startingHandle=0x000E,
                           endingHandle=0x0018,
                           attributeTypeSize=0x02,
                           attributeType=0x2803
                         }


+8923 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_READ_BY_TYPE_IND{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           length=0x0017,
                           attributeTypeSize=0x02,
                           attributeType=0x2803,
                           ElementCount=03,
                           AttributeSize=07,
                           Handle=000F,
                           AttrValue=2A63001010,
                           Handle=0012,
                           AttrValue=2A65001302,
                           Handle=0014,
                           AttrValue=2A5D001502
                         }


+8938 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_READ_BY_TYPE_RSP{
                           				{
                             handle=0x000F
					value{
                               Properties=0x10,
                               Handle=0x0010,
                               UUID=0x2A63
                             }

                           }
				{
                             handle=0x0012
					value{
                               Properties=0x02,
                               Handle=0x0013,
                               UUID=0x2A65
                             }

                           }
				{
                             handle=0x0014
					value{
                               Properties=0x02,
                               Handle=0x0015,
                               UUID=0x2A5D
                             }

                           }

                         }


+9079 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_READ_BY_TYPE_IND{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           length=0x0009,
                           attributeTypeSize=0x02,
                           attributeType=0x2803,
                           ElementCount=01,
                           AttributeSize=07,
                           Handle=0016,
                           AttrValue=2A66001728
                         }


+9079 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_READ_BY_TYPE_RSP{
                           				{
                             handle=0x0016
					value{
                               Properties=0x28,
                               Handle=0x0017,
                               UUID=0x2A66
                             }

                           }

                         }


+9235 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_READ_BY_TYPE_CFM{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeType=0x2803,
                           attributeTypeSize=0x02,
                           result=0x0000,
                           errorHandle=0x0000
                         }


+9235 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_READ_BY_TYPE_CFM{
                           				{
                             handle=0x000F
					value{
                               Properties=0x10,
                               Handle=0x0010,
                               UUID=0x2A63
                             }

                           }
				{
                             handle=0x0012
					value{
                               Properties=0x02,
                               Handle=0x0013,
                               UUID=0x2A65
                             }

                           }
				{
                             handle=0x0014
					value{
                               Properties=0x02,
                               Handle=0x0015,
                               UUID=0x2A5D
                             }

                           }
				{
                             handle=0x0016
					value{
                               Properties=0x28,
                               Handle=0x0017,
                               UUID=0x2A66
                             }

                           }

                         }


+9235 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+9235 ms
Verdict Description:     Discover All Characteristics of Service Request completed successfully.



+9235 ms
Send Event:              ATT!ATT_FIND_INFO_REQ{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           startingHandle=0x0011,
                           endingHandle=0x0011
                         }


+9453 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_FIND_INFO_RSP{
                           				{
                             handle=0x0011,
                             uuid=0x2902
					
                           }
                         }


+9453 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_FIND_INFO_CFM{
                           				{
                             handle=0x0011,
                             uuid=0x2902,
                             
					
                           }
                         }


+9453 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+9453 ms
Verdict Description:     Discover All Characteristic Descriptors Request completed successfully.



+9453 ms
Send Event:              ATT!ATT_FIND_INFO_REQ{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           startingHandle=0x0018,
                           endingHandle=0x0018
                         }


+9609 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_FIND_INFO_RSP{
                           				{
                             handle=0x0018,
                             uuid=0x2902
					
                           }
                         }


+9609 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_FIND_INFO_CFM{
                           				{
                             handle=0x0018,
                             uuid=0x2902,
                             
					
                           }
                         }


+9609 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+9609 ms
Verdict Description:     Discover All Characteristic Descriptors Request completed successfully.



+9609 ms
Send Event:              ATT!ATT_WRITE_REQ{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0018,
                           length=0x0002,
                           0000
                         }


+9750 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_WRITE_CFM{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           result=0x0000,
                           errorHandle=0x0000
                         }


+9750 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+11263 ms
Send Event:              ATT!ATT_WRITE_REQ{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0018,
                           length=0x0002,
                           0002
                         }


+11403 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_WRITE_CFM{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           result=0x0000,
                           errorHandle=0x0000
                         }


+11403 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+11403 ms
Send Event:              ATT!ATT_WRITE_REQ{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0011,
                           length=0x0002,
                           0000
                         }


+11622 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_WRITE_CFM{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           result=0x0000,
                           errorHandle=0x0000
                         }


+11622 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+13150 ms
Send Event:              ATT!ATT_WRITE_REQ{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0011,
                           length=0x0002,
                           0001
                         }


+13275 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_WRITE_CFM{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           result=0x0000,
                           errorHandle=0x0000
                         }


+13275 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+13275 ms
Send Event:              ATT!ATT_READ_REQ{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0013
                         }


+13431 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_READ_CFM{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           length=0x0004,
                           result=0x0100,
                           errorHandle=0x0000,
                           value{
                             CyclingPowerFeature=0x0011020A
                           }

                         }


+13431 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+13431 ms
Verdict Description:     Read Request completed successfully. Handle=0x0013



+13431 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+13431 ms
Pass:                    The data received for 'Cycling Power Feature' conforms to the schema



+13431 ms
Verdict Description:     The data received for 'Cycling Power Feature' conforms to the schema



+13431 ms
Send Event:              ATT!ATT_WRITE_REQ{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0017,
                           length=0x0001,
                           0C
                         }


+13572 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_WRITE_CFM{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           result=0x0000,
                           errorHandle=0x0000
                         }


+13572 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+13572 ms
Verdict Description:     Waiting for indication on handle = 0x0017 for Characteristic 'Cycling Power Control Point' (UUID = 0x2A66)



+13587 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_HANDLE_VALUE_NOTIFICATION_IND{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0010,
                           length=0x000A,
                           attributeValue=0x0000000000000000002C
                         }


+14632 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_HANDLE_VALUE_NOTIFICATION_IND{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0010,
                           length=0x000A,
                           attributeValue=0x0000000000000000002C
                         }


+15600 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_HANDLE_VALUE_NOTIFICATION_IND{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0010,
                           length=0x000A,
                           attributeValue=0x0000000000000000002C
                         }


+16582 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_HANDLE_VALUE_NOTIFICATION_IND{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0010,
                           length=0x000A,
                           attributeValue=0x0000000000000000002C
                         }


+16582 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_HANDLE_VALUE_IND{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0017,
                           length=0x0005,
                           attributeValue=0x0001010C20
                         }


+16582 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+16598 ms
Pass:                    The value for 'Cycling Power Control Point' sent by the IUT was correctly formatted.



+16598 ms
Verdict Description:     The value for 'Cycling Power Control Point' sent by the IUT was correctly formatted.



+16598 ms
Send Event:              ATT!ATT_WRITE_REQ{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0017,
                           length=0x0001,
                           0C
                         }


+16723 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_WRITE_CFM{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           result=0x0000,
                           errorHandle=0x0000
                         }


+16723 ms
Preliminary Verdict:     PASS



+16723 ms
Verdict Description:     Write Request completed successfully.



+16723 ms
Verdict Description:     Waiting for indication on handle = 0x0017 for Characteristic 'Cycling Power Control Point' (UUID = 0x2A66)



+17628 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_HANDLE_VALUE_NOTIFICATION_IND{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0010,
                           length=0x000A,
                           attributeValue=0x0000000000000000002C
                         }


+18236 ms
Receive Event:           L2CAP?L2CAP_LE_CONNECTION_UPDATE_IND{
                           peerAddr=0xCC52D3B4B51F,
                           peerAddrType=HCI_LE_RANDOM_DEVICE_ADDRESS,
                           minInterval=0x0014,
                           maxInterval=0x0028,
                           slaveLatency=0x0000,
                           supervision_timeout=0x01F4
                         }


+18236 ms
Send Event:              L2CAP!L2CA_LE_CONNECTION_UPDATE_RSP{
                           peerAddr=0xCC52D3B4B51F,
                           peerAddrType=0x01,
                           paramAccepted=1
                         }


+18610 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_HANDLE_VALUE_NOTIFICATION_IND{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0010,
                           length=0x000A,
                           attributeValue=0x0000000000000000002C
                         }


+19578 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_HANDLE_VALUE_NOTIFICATION_IND{
                           lcid=0x1205,
                           attributeHandle=0x0010,
                           length=0x000A,
                           attributeValue=0x0000000000000000002C
                         }


+40544 ms
Receive Event:           ATT?ATT_DISCONNECT_IND{
                           lcid=0x1205
                         }


+40544 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_LE_DISCONNECTION_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK,
                           connectionHandle=0x0063,
                           reason=HCI_CONNECTION_TIMEOUT
                         }


+40544 ms
Verdict Description:     Unexpected ATT Disconnect received.



+40544 ms
Inconclusive:            Non-passing verdict returned from APICOM, see log for more details.



+40544 ms
Verdict Description:     Non-passing verdict returned from APICOM, see log for more details.



+42697 ms
Receive Event:           HCI?HCI_RESET_COMPLETE_EVENT{
                           status=HCI_OK
                         }


+43633 ms
Final Verdict:           INCONC



+43633 ms
Encrypted Verdict:       A1#ZWY4MzQ5MDg3MmQwNTIxOGQzMzQ5YjY2ODA5M2MzNjQ5ZDY4NmY0Yjc2MzIzM2VkNTUyNTFhNGU4Mjg1MjI0NA==#mpduB7T8LvovABj6T4Gu+NaqZZp5djc+JHVvJvU+j6aMa6oiCklRuq5sE+AhiaFT


+43633 ms
Test Case Ended:         CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C

</LOG>
  <SUMMARY>Test case : CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C started
	- Connection setup successfully.
	- Tester successfully initiated connection.
	- LE Security not initiated due to TSPX_security_enabled value.
	- Discover Primary Service by Service UUID Request completed successfully.
	- The IUT successfully returned the UUID for Cycling Power
	- Discover All Characteristics of Service Request completed successfully.
	- Discover All Characteristic Descriptors Request completed successfully.
	- Discover All Characteristic Descriptors Request completed successfully.
	- Read Request completed successfully. Handle=0x0013
	- The data received for 'Cycling Power Feature' conforms to the schema
	- Waiting for indication on handle = 0x0017 for Characteristic 'Cycling Power Control Point' (UUID = 0x2A66)
	- The value for 'Cycling Power Control Point' sent by the IUT was correctly formatted.
	- Write Request completed successfully.
	- Waiting for indication on handle = 0x0017 for Characteristic 'Cycling Power Control Point' (UUID = 0x2A66)
	- Unexpected ATT Disconnect received.
	- Non-passing verdict returned from APICOM, see log for more details.
Final Verdict:INCONC
CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C finished
</SUMMARY>
</ARCHIVE>

RE: CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

cavalihno — Fri, 24 Apr 2020 13:11:30 GMT

Hello Kioshi,

Can I ask you how did you solve this problem?

Thanks,

Marcin Kawalec

RE: CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

Kiyoshi Iwai — Fri, 19 Oct 2018 03:38:00 GMT

Hello Kenneth,

Thank you so much for your help.

But the certification laboratory has the tester, we don't. So we could not take a sniffer log.

I'm sorry.

BTW, we got the PASS result of all BLE test at last night, we finished this problem.

Thanks,

Kiyoshi Iwai

RE: CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

Kenneth — Thu, 18 Oct 2018 19:25:14 GMT

Hi Kiyoshi ,

If you are able to provide an on-air sniffer log I think I will be able to find why link timeout and disconnect 20 seconds after:

  +21777 ms
  Send Event: ATT!ATT_WRITE_REQ{
  lcid=0x0040,
  attributeHandle=0x0018,
  length=0x0001,
  value{  OpCode=0x0C,  CyclingPowerVectorControlValue=0x0063  }  }   +21902 ms  Receive Event: ATT?ATT_WRITE_CFM{  lcid=0x0040,  result=0x0100,  errorHandle=0x0000  }   +21902 ms  Preliminary Verdict: PASS   +22511 ms  Receive Event: ATT?ATT_HANDLE_VALUE_NOTIFICATION_REQ{  lcid=0x0040,  attributeHandle=0x0011,  length=0x000A,  attributeValue=0x00000000005B0000002C  }   +22511 ms  Receive Event: ATT?ATT_HANDLE_VALUE_IND{  lcid=0x0040,  attributeHandle=0x0018,  length=0x0005,  attributeValue=0x00FFFF010C20  }   +22511 ms  Preliminary Verdict: PASS   +22511 ms  Pass: The value for 'Cycling Power Control Point' sent by the IUT was correctly formatted.   +22511 ms  Verdict Description: The value for 'Cycling Power Control Point' sent by the IUT was correctly formatted.   +22511 ms  Send Event: ATT!ATT_WRITE_REQ{  lcid=0x0040,  attributeHandle=0x0018,  length=0x0001,  value{  OpCode=0x0C,  CyclingPowerVectorControlValue=0x006E  }  }   +22682 ms  Receive Event: ATT?ATT_WRITE_CFM{  lcid=0x0040,  result=0x0100,  errorHandle=0x0000
  }

Maybe you can send us your hardware and we can try to make a sniffer log here and I can ship it back afterwards.

Best regards,
Kenneth

RE: CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

Kiyoshi Iwai — Thu, 18 Oct 2018 06:20:03 GMT

Hello Kenneth,

Thank you for your polite reply.

The Test-log does not describe all transaction, I think.

But I have to pass this test because of getting the certificate of bluetooth SIG.

I will check whether receive the confirmation from the tester or not, and if I receive any requests

without the confirmation, I will send the Error Code which described the step 7 a) in the test specification.

Best regards,

Kiyoshi Iwai

RE: CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

Kenneth — Wed, 17 Oct 2018 08:54:31 GMT

Hi Kiyoshi,

I have taken a look at this case and log, but difficult to understand what is failing here.

The HCI_CONNECTION_TIMEOUT typically occurs if the link is lost (supervisor timeout should occurs after 20 seconds if there is no successful communication, from log: supervisionTimeout=0x07D0). However I am unsure why that is, it may be that there is an assert on the peripheral, then the peripheral will reset, and thereby the tester will wait for supervisor timeout before HCI_CONNECTION_TIMEOUT occurs.

To find the cause here I believe you need the source code for the peripheral, compile the project and enable debugging, so you can find what is happening (assert, timeout, or disconnect). Another option to find cause would be to get an on-air sniffer log, for instance using ellisys, frontline or the nrf sniffer tool.

It might be useful to receive the sdk_config.h from your project, so we can take a look at the lfclk parameters.

Looking at CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C I can't seem to find step 3 either, which is "The Lower Tester sets to 0x0002 the Client Characteristic Configuration descriptor of the Cycling Power Control Point characteristic.". So a sniffer log would be very helpful here.

I assume that the peripheral device doesn't support bonding here, since you have not enabled bonding (from log: LE Security not initiated due to TSPX_security_enabled value).

Best regards,
Kenneth

RE: CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

Kiyoshi Iwai — Wed, 17 Oct 2018 00:43:35 GMT

Did you find the test procedure of CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C in the test specification?

At the step 5 of this precedure, you can find that "the Lower Tester does not send any Confirmation to acknowledge this indication".

This is abnormal situation, I think.

Does any unexpected operation occur , if the soft device does not get the Confirmation?

RE: CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

Kiyoshi Iwai — Tue, 16 Oct 2018 10:19:40 GMT

Thank you for the information.

If the tester does not send the confirmation, the BLE_GATTS_EVT_HVC continues the pending state and approx.30 second passed(time-out expired) , will HCI_CONNECTION_TIMEOUT occur?

RE: CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

Simon — Tue, 16 Oct 2018 09:23:04 GMT

The received event ATT_DISCONNECT_REQ is misleading, I don't think the application sends any such request. However, I think the problem is that the clock goes out of sync and thus the error HCI_CONNECTION_TIMEOUT.

In order to test this, open the sdk_config.h file of your product. Then you will find the following lines (assuming you are using sdk 14):

// <o> NRF_SDH_CLOCK_LF_XTAL_ACCURACY  - External crystal clock accuracy used in the LL to compute timing windows.
 
// <0=> NRF_CLOCK_LF_XTAL_ACCURACY_250_PPM 
// <1=> NRF_CLOCK_LF_XTAL_ACCURACY_500_PPM 
// <2=> NRF_CLOCK_LF_XTAL_ACCURACY_150_PPM 
// <3=> NRF_CLOCK_LF_XTAL_ACCURACY_100_PPM 
// <4=> NRF_CLOCK_LF_XTAL_ACCURACY_75_PPM 
// <5=> NRF_CLOCK_LF_XTAL_ACCURACY_50_PPM 
// <6=> NRF_CLOCK_LF_XTAL_ACCURACY_30_PPM 
// <7=> NRF_CLOCK_LF_XTAL_ACCURACY_20_PPM 

#ifndef NRF_SDH_CLOCK_LF_XTAL_ACCURACY
#define NRF_SDH_CLOCK_LF_XTAL_ACCURACY 7
#endif

Then change the value to 1 (accuracy of 500 ppm), and check if the problem disappear.

RE: CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

Kiyoshi Iwai — Tue, 16 Oct 2018 08:56:16 GMT

Hello Simon,

I will send the test specification of BLE.

Please find the page 68

devzone.nordicsemi.com/.../CPS.TS.1.1.2.pdf

RE: CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

Kiyoshi Iwai — Mon, 15 Oct 2018 09:50:36 GMT

Hello Simon,

Thank you for reply.

Unfortunately I don't have the log of 613-616.

As you said, it took long time between two event, because this test may be abnormal check.

So could you tell me how to change the HCI_CONNECTION_TIMEOUT longer, or how to stop the ATT Disconnect Request?

Best regards,

Kiyoshi Iwai

RE: CPS/SEN/SPE/BI-04-C [Procedure Already In Progress] inconc

Simon — Mon, 15 Oct 2018 09:02:38 GMT

Could you provide a sniffer log of what happens between line 613 and 616 (Verdict Description and Receive Event)? The time span between these two event was quite long. Also, the HCI_CONNECTION_TIMEOUT might be due to a too low accuracy for the low frequency clock, check the value of NRF_SDH_CLOCK_LF_ACCURACY or what accuracy you have provided to sd_softdevice_enable(..).