Where I can find the migration guide from sdk 15.2 to sdk 15.3, please?

RE: Where I can find the migration guide from sdk 15.2 to sdk 15.3, please?

Simon — Wed, 10 Apr 2019 09:36:10 GMT

I am sorry if you've had a bad experience, and I can see that the changes may cause some trouble. Optimally, as I see it, you should be able move your project (along with the driver/library linking information) directly from SDK 15.2 to SDK 15.3, and the application should run without any modifications. However, if the sdk_config.h definitions have changed inside a function, the old sdk_config file won't be sufficient.

I am sure there are reasons behind these changes, but I am not sure what they are. Of the changes you listed, only one is an API change, specifically the functions in nrf_mpu.h. I searched through the entire SDK, and saw that these functions are never called directly. Either through nrf_stack_guard_init() in nrf_stack_guard.c or task_stack_protect() in task_manager.c, and if your project uses any of these functions you will be fine. It may be that the SDK developers have allowed API changes in this instance due to its limited direct usage.

Again, this is not optimal and I am sorry for the inconvenience you've experienced.

Best regards,

Simon

RE: Where I can find the migration guide from sdk 15.2 to sdk 15.3, please?

nine-fox — Sun, 07 Apr 2019 10:07:48 GMT

HI Simon,

Thanks for your asking. Well, its been a while, and I believe APIs are changed as follows:

1. nrf_mpu_lib, the old name is nrf_mpu

2. some definitions are added in sdk_config.h, including:

NRF_CRYPTO_BACKEND_CC310_BL_INTERRUPTS_ENABLED

NRF_DFU_IN_APP

NRF_DFU_APP_ACCEPT_SAME_VERSION

NRF_MPU_* all renamed to NRF_MPU_LIB*

NRFX_USBD_CONFIG_ISO_IN_ZLP

NRFX_USBD_CONFIG_DMASCHEDULER_ISO_BOOST

NRFX_USBD_CONFIG_DMASCHEDULER_MODE

Still, these are just what I found by comparing the sdk_config.h and looking into them one by one. It really costs. I am not sure whether I found all of them. Its quite bad experience when there is no doc related to these changes. It would be better to document them even it is rarely in use.

Thanks

RE: Where I can find the migration guide from sdk 15.2 to sdk 15.3, please?

Simon — Wed, 27 Mar 2019 16:20:47 GMT

You can take a look at the release notes for SDK 15.3 to see the changes done from SDK 15.2. If you download s132 v6.1.1 (the sd. used in SDK 15.3), you will find the release notes for the SoftDevice (and all the changes done). However, the API is not supposed to change, and if you have seen any, it is a bug.

Could you point out the API changes you have found?

Best regards,

Simon

RE: Where I can find the migration guide from sdk 15.2 to sdk 15.3, please?

nine-fox — Tue, 26 Mar 2019 01:45:11 GMT

Thanks for your reply!

I can see most of the code can work under 15.3. However, some code need change - if there is a list can describe the api changes, it would be better

RE: Where I can find the migration guide from sdk 15.2 to sdk 15.3, please?

Simon — Fri, 22 Mar 2019 16:47:44 GMT

Migration guides are only made when new SDK major version are created, e.g. when transitioning from SDK 14.x.x to 15.x.x. If you have created a project using SDK 15.2 it should work with SDK 15.3 as well, since the API stays the same.

Best regards,

Simon