Connection terminated by remote user, why?

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

PingISTL — Wed, 22 Jun 2022 11:19:44 GMT

Hi, Sigurd

I tried to call bt_gatt_discover_continue() afterwards and it works.

To find all services without knowing any UUID first, call bt_gatt_discover_start() with NULL as UUID and call bt_gatt_discover_continue() afterwards until no more service is discovered.

bt_gatt_discover_start() finds only 1 service at a time.

thanks for your help!

Ping

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

PingISTL — Tue, 21 Jun 2022 14:51:19 GMT

Just noticed you suggest to call bt_gatt_discover() function , while in my example, I call bt_gatt_discover_start() function. The later pass more parameters down and allow calling a callback function afterwards.

But what is the difference fundamentally? which one I should use ? do I need to call bt_gatt_discover_continue()?

Regards!

Ping

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

PingISTL — Tue, 21 Jun 2022 14:37:57 GMT

Hello, Sigurd

Thank you for reply.

I started from central BAS example, and call the following to do discovery.

err = bt_gatt_dm_start(conn, BT_UUID_BAS, &discovery_cb, NULL); //or NULL

when I pass BT_UUID_BAS as uuid, the service it found is printed as below:

The discovery procedure succeeded

ATT[1]:     UUID: 0x2803    Handle: 0x0011    Value:

    Characteristic: 0x2a19    Properties: 0x0012

ATT[2]:     UUID: 0x2a19    Handle: 0x0012    Value:

ATT[3]:     UUID: 0x2902    Handle: 0x0013    Value:

    CCCD

while when I pass NULL as uuid, following attributes are found - it is the mandatory Generic Attribute(0x1801) of the peripheral rather than BT_UUID_BAS.

The discovery procedure succeeded

ATT[1]:     UUID: 0x2803    Handle: 0x0002    Value:

    Characteristic: 0x2a05    Properties: 0x0020

ATT[2]:     UUID: 0x2a05    Handle: 0x0003    Value:

ATT[3]:     UUID: 0x2902    Handle: 0x0004    Value:

    CCCD

ATT[4]:     UUID: 0x2803    Handle: 0x0005    Value:

    Characteristic: 0x2b29    Properties: 0x000A

ATT[5]:     UUID: 0x2b29    Handle: 0x0006    Value:

ATT[6]:     UUID: 0x2803    Handle: 0x0007    Value:

    Characteristic: 0x2b2a    Properties: 0x0002

ATT[7]:     UUID: 0x2b2a    Handle: 0x0008    Value:

They are for same peripheral - the Nordic mouse one. I expect it to find all services include BT_UUID_BAS(0x180F) and another one 0x1812, and more. But it doesn't.

Could you explain what I have done wrong please? how can I find all without knowing the UUID in advance please?

Regards!

Ping

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

Sigurd — Mon, 20 Jun 2022 11:13:41 GMT

You can use the bt_gatt_discover() API for that. From: https://developer.nordicsemi.com/nRF_Connect_SDK/doc/1.9.1/zephyr/reference/bluetooth/gatt.html#generic-attribute-profile-gatt

"Discover procedures can be initiated with the use of bt_gatt_discover() API which takes the bt_gatt_discover_params struct which describes the type of discovery. The parameters also serves as a filter when setting the uuid field only attributes which matches will be discovered, in contrast setting it to NULL allows all attributes to be discovered."

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

PingISTL — Mon, 20 Jun 2022 10:59:10 GMT

I am developing a central app - a generic one applies to all peripherals hopefully, so need to figure out what other centrals do in terms of findings all services and UUIDs - there must be a procedure/way for these centrals like nRF Connect to follow to find all services available from any peripheral without knowing its protocols already - am I right?

Regards!

Ping

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

Sigurd — Mon, 20 Jun 2022 10:30:56 GMT

Probably easiest is to use e.g. nRF Connect Desktop BLE app, or nRF Connect for mobile app, connect to the device, and check out the services and UUIDs.

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

PingISTL — Fri, 17 Jun 2022 09:18:00 GMT

possibly, but some other peripherals do not do that - just stay connected even no activities going on.

I am about to do service discovery immediately after connection, have a question here - how do I determine which service UUID I pass to the discovery manager? for this particular one, it seems advertising manufacturer data which has its own manufacturer ID and 128 bits service UUID, so I presume I need to know the manufacturer's advertising data protocol ? is this published somewhere?

Thank you for your patience!

Ping

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

Sigurd — Fri, 17 Jun 2022 08:54:10 GMT

[quote user="PingISTL"]See the attachment please. It was caught a few days ago,[/quote]

Here we can see the central do a service discovery, does read requests, enables notifications, etc. So the activity here likely makes the connection stay alive. If there is no activity, you just connect, the slave in the other sniffer trace seems to detect that, and deliberately disconnects after a timeout period with no activity.

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

PingISTL — Thu, 16 Jun 2022 13:45:24 GMT

devzone.nordicsemi.com/.../CEConnectWithPhone.pcapng

Hi, Sigurd

See the attachment please. It was caught a few days ago, I tried to do it again today and unfortunately, the sniffer doesn't work for me now. It sees advertisng packets, but doean't seems catch the connection activities. Not sure why.

Thank you!

Ping

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

PingISTL — Thu, 16 Jun 2022 13:00:21 GMT

I will try to catch it and send, thanks!

Ping

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

Sigurd — Thu, 16 Jun 2022 12:50:44 GMT

[quote userid="113482" url="~/f/nordic-q-a/88982/connection-terminated-by-remote-user-why/372817#372817"]BeaconSimulator is able to talk to it without being disconnected.[/quote]

Hmm, do you have sniffer trace with that? So we can compare it with the other sniffer trace?

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

PingISTL — Thu, 16 Jun 2022 12:45:42 GMT

Hi, thanks

I will try to read the apple development support.

nrf connect app seems to be same, but another app - BeaconSimulator is able to talk to it without being disconnected.

I tried change connection parameters, and doesn't help, any thing you could think?

Ping

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

Sigurd — Thu, 16 Jun 2022 11:40:22 GMT

Ok, I see. Maybe you could try the Apple Developer Support. https://developer.apple.com/support/

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

PingISTL — Thu, 16 Jun 2022 11:27:05 GMT

Unfortunately, this is one of Apple's product, and I don't have source code to access it, my project now is develop an central application talking to other peripherals like this one.

Thank for reply!

Ping

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

Sigurd — Thu, 16 Jun 2022 11:21:04 GMT

[quote user="PingISTL"]seems like the slave is initiate the LL_TERMINTE_IND, am I right?[/quote]

Correct. The slaves terminates the connection. If you have the firmware for this slave, then as mentioned, it's likely calling bt_conn_disconnect() somewhere, and maybe you can try place a breakpoint at these locations, debug and find out why it's being called.

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

PingISTL — Wed, 15 Jun 2022 15:01:38 GMT

slave is Apple device -AC233F8153CE, it is a beacon. Master is my central app or phone.

Ping

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

Sigurd — Wed, 15 Jun 2022 14:49:54 GMT

[quote user="PingISTL"]the highlighted line on No 329, seems like the slave is initiate the LL_TERMINTE_IND, am I right? [/quote]

Is the slave the nRF52 or the apple device?

AC233F8153CE is nrf52 or apple device?

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

PingISTL — Wed, 15 Jun 2022 13:06:38 GMT

Hi, Sigurd

I don't think my application is calling the disconnect function somewhere, here is the screenshot for it. the highlighted line on No 329, seems like the slave is initiate the LL_TERMINTE_IND, am I right?

Also, it happens with nrf Connect mobile app when I try to connect it with my phone. But this doesn't happen with BeaconSimulator App running on phone.

Regards!

Ping

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

Sigurd — Wed, 15 Jun 2022 12:12:21 GMT

Your application is likely calling bt_conn_disconnect() somewhere. Maybe you can place a breakpoint at these locations, and debug and find out why it's being called.

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

PingISTL — Wed, 15 Jun 2022 12:01:58 GMT

Hello, Sigurd

Thanks for reply, here is the sniffer log for it, the device MAC address is AC233F8153CE.

devzone.nordicsemi.com/.../CEconnect_2600_disconnect.pcapng

Regards!

Ping

RE: Connection terminated by remote user, why?

Sigurd — Wed, 15 Jun 2022 09:09:13 GMT

Hi,

A sniffer trace might give us some more insight to what happens. Please capture a sniffer trace of the behavior. https://www.nordicsemi.com/Products/Development-tools/nRF-Sniffer-for-Bluetooth-LE