ADC Infuriating Behaviour With Multi-channel Scan Using PPI to RTC

[snoopy20]

Been on all day at this and ready to smash something! :)

I need to do three 'steps' or 'tasks' which are:

1. read 5 channels
2. read 3 channels, which are the same as above minus two (there's a pin aux)
3. read 2 channels repeatedly filling up one of two banks with additional looping.

For brevity I've removed (3) to just do a single read and then call (1).

Each step works from adc interrupt. In the case of (1) and (2) the SAMPLE is wired to STARTED by PPI. Primarily this is because the RTC tick at 32KHz) is too fast.

Then this PPI is disabled and the RTC TICK EVENT is wired to STARTED instead. This gives 30.5us, and the 2 channels plus overhead are well within it.

Behaviour

The routine(s) loop twice and then end with no further interrupts. I believe the ADC is stuck on (2) because the TICK EVENT isn't being pumped through when the PPI channel is re-enabled.

I think I've tried everything to get this working but maybe another pair of eyes could help! 

extern struct statusProto status;

#define ADC_RESOLUTION SAADC_RESOLUTION_VAL_12bit
#define ADC_SAMPLETIME_CFG_SLOW SAADC_CH_CONFIG_TACQ_40us
#define ADC_SAMPLETIME_CFG_MPPT_VOLTAGE SAADC_CH_CONFIG_TACQ_10us
#define ADC_SAMPLETIME_CFG_MPPT_CURRENT SAADC_CH_CONFIG_TACQ_10us

// ADC takes 2us per channel, 4us + 15us + 5us = 24us

// 32,768Hz = 30.52us
// 667 (fit into ram)*30 = 20ms
#define MPPT_SAMPLES 1

// 200ms total / 20ms
#define MPPT_LOOP 2

enum {
  ADC_CH_USB,
  ADC_CH_FRONT,
  ADC_CH_REAR,
  ADC_CH_STORE,
  ADC_CH_LIGHTSENSE,
  ADC_CH_MPPT_VOLTAGE,
  ADC_CH_MPPT_CURRENT
};

struct mpptReadProto {
  int16_t voltage;
  int16_t current;
};

struct {
  volatile struct {
    int16_t usb;
    int16_t front;
    int16_t rear;
    int16_t storage;
    int16_t lightsense;
  } voltages;
  volatile struct {
    int16_t usb;
    int16_t front;
    int16_t rear;
  } currents;
  struct mpptReadProto banks[2][MPPT_SAMPLES];
} reads;

static void step3n (void);
static void step3 (void);
static void step2 (void);
static void step1 (void);

static void (*step)(void);
static uint8_t loop;
static struct mpptTrackProto track;
static struct mpptReadProto *currentBank;

static void step1 (void) {

  step = &step2;

  NRF_PPI->CHENSET = 1 << CFG_PPI_ADC_SAMPLEONSTART;

  NRF_GPIO->OUTCLR = 1 << CFG_PIN_ADC_MUX;

  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_USB].PSELP = CFG_ADC_USB_PSEL;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_FRONT].PSELP = CFG_ADC_FRONT_PSEL;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_REAR].PSELP = CFG_ADC_REAR_PSEL;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_STORE].PSELP = CFG_ADC_STORE_PSEL;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_LIGHTSENSE].PSELP = CFG_ADC_LIGHTSENSE_PSEL;
  NRF_SAADC->RESULT.PTR = (uint32_t) &reads.voltages;
  NRF_SAADC->RESULT.MAXCNT = sizeof(reads.voltages) / 2;
  NRF_SAADC->TASKS_START = SAADC_TASKS_START_TASKS_START_Trigger << SAADC_TASKS_START_TASKS_START_Pos; 
}

static void step2 (void) {

  step = &step3;

  NRF_GPIO->OUTSET = 1 << CFG_PIN_ADC_MUX;
  // rather than wait for adc task compute we do here and send as event
  // this is only benefical if the storage read is greater than 500ms (adc task)
  if (reads.voltages.storage < STORAGE_VOLTAGE_CRITICAL_ON) {
    POWERMANAGER_EventStorageCritical();
  }

  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_STORE].PSELP = SAADC_CH_PSELP_PSELP_NC;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_LIGHTSENSE].PSELP = SAADC_CH_PSELP_PSELP_NC;
  NRF_SAADC->RESULT.PTR = (uint32_t) &reads.currents;
  NRF_SAADC->RESULT.MAXCNT = sizeof(reads.currents) / 2;
  NRF_SAADC->TASKS_START = SAADC_TASKS_START_TASKS_START_Trigger << SAADC_TASKS_START_TASKS_START_Pos; 
}

static void step3 (void) {

  currentBank = &reads.banks[0][0];
  step = &step3n;

  NRF_PPI->CHENCLR = 1 << CFG_PPI_ADC_SAMPLEONSTART;

  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_USB].PSELP = SAADC_CH_PSELP_PSELP_NC;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_FRONT].PSELP = SAADC_CH_PSELP_PSELP_NC;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_REAR].PSELP = SAADC_CH_PSELP_PSELP_NC;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_MPPT_VOLTAGE].PSELP = CFG_ADC_MPPT_VOLTAGE_PSEL;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_MPPT_CURRENT].PSELP = CFG_ADC_MPPT_CURRENT_PSEL;
  NRF_SAADC->RESULT.PTR = (uint32_t) &reads.banks[0];
  NRF_SAADC->RESULT.MAXCNT = sizeof(reads.banks[0]) / sizeof(reads.banks[0][0]);
  NRF_SAADC->TASKS_START = SAADC_TASKS_START_TASKS_START_Trigger << SAADC_TASKS_START_TASKS_START_Pos;
  NRF_PPI->CHENSET = 1 << CFG_PPI_ADC_SAMPLEBYTIMER;
}


static void step3n (void) {

  // code cut down to remove looping
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_MPPT_VOLTAGE].PSELP = SAADC_CH_PSELP_PSELP_NC;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_MPPT_CURRENT].PSELP = SAADC_CH_PSELP_PSELP_NC;
  NRF_PPI->CHENCLR = 1 << CFG_PPI_ADC_SAMPLEBYTIMER;
  step1();
}

void SAADC_IRQHandler (void) {

  NRF_SAADC->EVENTS_END = SAADC_EVENTS_END_EVENTS_END_NotGenerated << SAADC_EVENTS_END_EVENTS_END_Pos;
  step();
}

uint32_t ADC_TaskCalibrate (void) {

  NRF_SAADC->ENABLE = SAADC_ENABLE_ENABLE_Enabled << SAADC_ENABLE_ENABLE_Pos;
  NRF_SAADC->TASKS_CALIBRATEOFFSET = SAADC_TASKS_CALIBRATEOFFSET_TASKS_CALIBRATEOFFSET_Trigger << SAADC_TASKS_CALIBRATEOFFSET_TASKS_CALIBRATEOFFSET_Pos;
  return CFG_SCHEDULER_TIMER_MINIMUM;
}

uint32_t ADC_TaskStart (void) {

  NRF_SAADC->EVENTS_END = SAADC_EVENTS_END_EVENTS_END_NotGenerated << SAADC_EVENTS_END_EVENTS_END_Pos;
  NRF_SAADC->INTENSET = SAADC_INTENSET_END_Enabled << SAADC_INTENSET_END_Pos;
  
  // Note RTC Event tick is enabled elsewhere!

  step1();
  return CFG_SCHEDULER_TIMER_MINIMUM;
}


inline void ADC_Init (void) {

  NRF_GPIO->PIN_CNF[CFG_PIN_ADC_STORE] = pinDisconnectInputBuffer;
  NRF_GPIO->PIN_CNF[CFG_PIN_ADC_USB] = pinDisconnectInputBuffer;
  NRF_GPIO->PIN_CNF[CFG_PIN_ADC_FRONT] = pinDisconnectInputBuffer;
  NRF_GPIO->PIN_CNF[CFG_PIN_ADC_REAR] = pinDisconnectInputBuffer;
  NRF_GPIO->PIN_CNF[CFG_PIN_ADC_MPPT_VOLTAGE] = pinDisconnectInputBuffer;
  NRF_GPIO->PIN_CNF[CFG_PIN_ADC_MPPT_CURRENT] = pinDisconnectInputBuffer;
  NRF_GPIO->PIN_CNF[CFG_PIN_ADC_LIGHTSENSE] = pinDisconnectInputBuffer;
  NRF_GPIO->PIN_CNF[CFG_PIN_ADC_MUX] = pinDisconnectInputBuffer | (GPIO_PIN_CNF_DIR_Output << GPIO_PIN_CNF_DIR_Pos);
  NRF_GPIO->OUTSET = 1 << CFG_PIN_ADC_MUX;

  NRF_SAADC->RESOLUTION = SAADC_RESOLUTION_VAL_12bit << SAADC_RESOLUTION_VAL_Pos;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_USB].CONFIG = SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Internal << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Pos | SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Gain1 << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Pos | ADC_SAMPLETIME_CFG_SLOW << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_TACQ_Pos;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_FRONT].CONFIG = SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Internal << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Pos | SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Gain1 << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Pos | ADC_SAMPLETIME_CFG_SLOW << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_TACQ_Pos;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_REAR].CONFIG = SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Internal << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Pos | SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Gain1 << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Pos | ADC_SAMPLETIME_CFG_SLOW << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_TACQ_Pos;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_STORE].CONFIG = SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Internal << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Pos | SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Gain1_2 << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Pos | ADC_SAMPLETIME_CFG_SLOW << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_TACQ_Pos;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_LIGHTSENSE].CONFIG = SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Internal << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Pos | SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Gain2 << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Pos | ADC_SAMPLETIME_CFG_SLOW << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_TACQ_Pos;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_MPPT_VOLTAGE].CONFIG = SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Internal << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Pos | SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Gain1_6 << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Pos | ADC_SAMPLETIME_CFG_MPPT_VOLTAGE << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_TACQ_Pos;
  NRF_SAADC->CH[ADC_CH_MPPT_CURRENT].CONFIG = SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Internal << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_REFSEL_Pos | SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Gain1_6 << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_GAIN_Pos | ADC_SAMPLETIME_CFG_MPPT_CURRENT << SAADC_CH_CONFIG_TACQ_Pos;
  
  NRF_PPI->CH[CFG_PPI_ADC_SAMPLEONSTART].EEP = (uint32_t) &NRF_SAADC->EVENTS_STARTED;
  NRF_PPI->CH[CFG_PPI_ADC_SAMPLEONSTART].TEP = (uint32_t) &NRF_SAADC->TASKS_SAMPLE;
  NRF_PPI->CH[CFG_PPI_ADC_SAMPLEBYTIMER].EEP = (uint32_t) &NRF_RTC1->EVENTS_TICK;
  NRF_PPI->CH[CFG_PPI_ADC_SAMPLEBYTIMER].TEP = (uint32_t) &NRF_SAADC->TASKS_SAMPLE;
  
  NVIC_SetPriority(SAADC_IRQn, CFG_INTERRUPT_PRIORITY_ADC);
  NVIC_EnableIRQ(SAADC_IRQn);
}

void ADC_Shutdown (void) {

  NRF_SAADC->ENABLE = SAADC_ENABLE_ENABLE_Disabled << SAADC_ENABLE_ENABLE_Pos;
}

[snoopy20]

I have used DSB() in the past, I tried a smattering after all the SAADC registers but to no avail.

After debugging and waiting for a while I managed to capture the failure. The reads have shifted one in ram.

I then checked all the PELP registers upon this occurrence and they're all correct.

Given there is some shift errata around the calibration (although I've disabled calibration) I decided to try wiring END to STOP.

NRF_PPI->CH[CFG_PPI_ADC_ENDAUTOSTOP].EEP = (uint32_t) &NRF_SAADC->EVENTS_END;
NRF_PPI->CH[CFG_PPI_ADC_ENDAUTOSTOP].TEP = (uint32_t) &NRF_SAADC->TASKS_STOP;
NRF_PPI->CH[CFG_PPI_ADC_CALIBRATEAUTOSTOP].EEP = (uint32_t) &NRF_SAADC->EVENTS_CALIBRATEDONE;
NRF_PPI->CH[CFG_PPI_ADC_CALIBRATEAUTOSTOP].TEP = (uint32_t) &NRF_SAADC->TASKS_STOP;

I then switched the interrupt to STOP.

I'm still running and praying but so far no further shifting!

[snoopy20]

I am simply delighted to say this is resolved!

I hope the Nordic team can create an errata and use the two PPI solution above not only for calibration but for scan operations. 

[hmolesworth]

Nice! Is this for off-grid solar, by any chance? I'll keep an eye out for more exciting problems ..

[snoopy20]

Similar, a generator.


So after much testing yesterday it occasionally would skip, which in my case is a fatal flaw that can damage hardware. I literally exhausted everything and then finally went the whole hog and used the errata code before any adc operation to do a full reset and reconfig. This has solved it.

  volatile uint32_t temp1;
  volatile uint32_t temp2;
  volatile uint32_t temp3;
  temp1 = *(volatile uint32_t *)0x40007640ul;
  temp2 = *(volatile uint32_t *)0x40007644ul;
  temp3 = *(volatile uint32_t *)0x40007648ul;
  *(volatile uint32_t *)0x40007FFCul = 0ul; 
  *(volatile uint32_t *)0x40007FFCul; 
  *(volatile uint32_t *)0x40007FFCul = 1ul;
  *(volatile uint32_t *)0x40007640ul = temp1;
  *(volatile uint32_t *)0x40007644ul = temp2;
  *(volatile uint32_t *)0x40007648ul = temp3;

My understanding (be good if someone from Nordic can verify) is that this will also reset internal calibration values if ran.

[Karl Ylvisaker]

Hello,

snoopy20 said:

So after much testing yesterday it occasionally would skip, which in my case is a fatal flaw that can damage hardware. I literally exhausted everything and then finally went the whole hog and used the errata code before any adc operation to do a full reset and reconfig. This has solved it.

I am sorry to read the struggles you've had to get this working as expected, which no doubt was a frustrating experience!

My general suggestion for your setup would be to use the SAADC driver and to have the sampling triggered through PPI with the addition described in this answer by my colleague Jørgen referenced by hmolesworth earlier, but you would of course also need to pay heed to the erratas also mentioned by hmolesworth, which sounds close to what you are doing currently.

snoopy20 said:

My understanding (be good if someone from Nordic can verify) is that this will also reset internal calibration values if ran.

Correct, adding this code will reset the entire SAADC peripheral, as mentioned in the workaround description. The offset calibration would indeed have to be run again, which should be done before you have started sampling (or after the END event, as described in the erratas), or anytime the ambient temperature has changed more than 10 degrees to counteract changes in the measurements caused by temperature. 
Are there anything else than the offset calibration you are referring to here, when you say 'internal calibration values'?

Best regards,
Karl