Need help to improve Bluetooth Mesh throughput

[aleccontrol]

I am currently using two nRF52832 SDK boards to implement text message exchange with another nRF52832 SDK board via BLE Mesh.

I based my development on the Light Switch example that was included with the Mesh SDK 1.0.0 

One of the board was based on the Lightswitch Client and the other board is based on Lightswitch Server.

I added two opcodes to the original _SET, _GET, _SET_UNRELIABLE and _STATUS. One opcode is called "SEND_COMMAND "and the second opcode is "SEND_RESPONSE".  I avoided building a custom model at this time so that I can avoid any issue with the provisioning. The main purpose is to test the throughput and latency to see if it is useable for a new product that we are developing.

The client board is programmed to send a text string about 15 characters. The opcode "SEND_COMMAND" is appended to the message.opcode together with a data structure that contains the text string and the length. The "access_model_publish() function is called to send out the packet. The command is published to a group address so that all the servers board will receive the command (currently I only have 1 server connected but the plan is to have all servers that subscribed to the group to receive the command in future)

The server board upon receiving the packet will decode the packet and then send a response. The response is sent with the opcode "SEND_RESPONSE" together with a response string of about 20 characters back to the client. The server too send the response using "access_model_publish()" function.

So far the application codes on both the client and server works well when triggering the client once a second to send the command text string and it does receive the response text string from the server most of the time. 

However, when I try to increase the frequency of sending the command the communication seem to choke. The client could barely send and receive more than 2 command/response packets per second before it starts to choke and lose communication. Once the client stop sending the command you can see some of  the previous packets being sent through but could take a few seconds to complete.

Has anyone experienced the same kind of throughput issue as I did? Is there any parameters that I can adjust to increase the throughput? I read somewhere on this forum that it may be possible for a node to send message of up to 24Hz (I assume it means the client could send up to 24 packets a second) but currently I could not even send and receive faster than 2 packets a second.

Hopefully anyone who has gone through the same experience could point me to possible solutions.

Thank you!

[Susheel Nuguru]

Hi Alecontrol,

Sorry for the delayed answer. Can you please upload the source files for us to be able to reproduce this issue.

[aleccontrol]

simple_on_off.zip

Thanks for your reply.

I have attached the modified files for the "simple_on_off_client", "simple_on_off_server" used for testing.

Client

To test the command/response, add the following code fragment to the main.c in the simple_on_off_client project:

    extern uint32_t send_command_client(simple_on_off_client_t * p_client, uint8_t *command, uint16_t length);

    uint8_t command[] = "Test";
        status = send_command_client(&m_clients[GROUP_CLIENT_INDEX], command, 4);

Note: I have edited the length to 4 (was 9 when first posted) since the command string now only contains 4 bytes)

Server

The simple_on_off_server has been modified so that it will simply copy the message it received and echo back to the client as a response package.

The client will run the function "handle_response_cb() when it receives the response from the server. You can log the response it received from the server. In our program we actually send the message out of the UART that requires to link with the app_uart files so you can simply comment out the call to "com1_strout() in our program".

Thank you if you can share with us your finding and suggested solutions.

[vishal]

Hi,

I am also trying to send text message over ble mesh but until not find solution.

Can you provide me your light switch main.c file. I have download the above .zip file but try to send simple test message but this also not send. Please help me for send text message client to server.

Thanks..