Mesh Elements Subscribe of Proxy Light Switch Client can't receive 2nd Publish of Proxy Light Switch Server

[Rex1979]

Hi ~

   SDK: nrf5_SDK_for_Mesh_v2_0_1 's ligth switch proxy client & proxy server
   IDEs : SEGGER Embedded Studio for ARM
              Release 3.40  Build 2018052200.36079
              Windows x64
   SoftDevices : s132_nrf52_6.0.0_softdevice
   Computer platform : Windows10
   hardware revisions : PCA10040 V1.1.0

  Element 0x0004 can't receive Element 0x0002 As shown.

[Mttrinh]

Can you give me a step by step procedure so I can reproduce the issue?

[Rex1979]

Hi Mttrinh,

Step1: Program s140_nrf52_6.0.0_softdevice.hex and light_switch_proxy_client_nrf52840_xxAA_s140_6.0.0.hex to PCA10056, that call it A.
Step2: Program s132_nrf52_6.0.0_softdevice.hex and light_switch_proxy_server_nrf52832_xxAA_s132_6.0.0.hex to two PCA10040s, that call it B and C.
Step3: A and B trun off, C trun on.
Step4: Open nRF Mesh for Andriod APP , that call it APP , Press Scanner in APP.
Step5: Find "nRF5x Mesh Light" in APP , that Press it.
Step6: Then press "PROVISION" in APP .
Step7: Wait for "Confguration Complete" in APP, that press "OK" in APP.
Step8: A and C trun off, B trun on.
Step9: Press Scanner in APP.
Step10: Find "nRF5x Mesh Light" in APP , that Press it.
Step11: Then press "PROVISION" in APP .
Step12: Wait for "Confguration Complete" in APP, that press "OK" in APP.
Step13: B and C trun off, A trun on.
Step14: Press Scanner in APP.
Step15: Find "nRF5x Mesh Switch" in APP , that Press it.
Step16: Then press "PROVISION" in APP .
Step17: Wait for "Confguration Complete" in APP, that press "OK" in APP.
Step18: Press "Network" in APP , You will get .
Step19: A and B,C trun on.
Step20: Press "CONFIGURE" in APP at C.
Step21: Press "Element : 0001" in APP , then Press "Vendor Model" in APP.
Step22: Then Press "BIND KEY" in APP, then Press "App Key 1".
Step23: Press "SET PUBLISH ADDRESS" in APP, Key in "C001" then Press "OK".
Step24: Press "SUBSCRIBE" in APP, Key in "C002" then Press "OK".
Step25: Press "<-" , then press "<-" , Back to Network.
Step26: Press "CONFIGURE" in APP at B.
Step27: Press "Element : 0002" in APP , then Press "Vendor Model" in APP.
Step28: Then Press "BIND KEY" in APP, then Press "App Key 1".
Step29: Press "SET PUBLISH ADDRESS" in APP, Key in "C001" then Press "OK".
Step30: Press "SUBSCRIBE" in APP, Key in "C002" then Press "OK".
Step31: Press "<-" , then press "<-" , Back to Network.
Step32: Press "CONFIGURE" in APP at A.
Step33: Press "Element : 0004" in APP , then Press "Vendor Model" in APP.
Step34: Then Press "BIND KEY" in APP, then Press "App Key 1".
Step35: Press "SET PUBLISH ADDRESS" in APP, Key in "0001" then Press "OK".
Step36: Press "SUBSCRIBE" in APP, Key in "C001" then Press "OK".
Step37: Press "<-" , Back to Node Configuration.
Step38: Press "Element : 0006" in APP , then Press "Vendor Model" in APP.
Step39: Then Press "BIND KEY" in APP, then Press "App Key 1".
Step40: Press "SET PUBLISH ADDRESS" in APP, Key in "C002" then Press "OK".
Step41: Press "Button 3" in A, watch B and C LED1 state , is good.
Step42: Press "Button 1" in C, watch A LED1 state, is good.
Step43: Press "Button 1" in B, watch A LED1 state, is no good.
as "question 001.png" , sorry "Element : 0005" change "Element : 0006".

Step44: Back to Network.
Step45: Press "CONFIGURE" in APP at A.
Step46: Press "Element : 0004" in APP , then Press "Vendor Model" in APP.
Step47: Press "SET PUBLISH ADDRESS" in APP, Key in "0002" then Press "OK".
Step48: Press "Button 3" in A, watch B and C LED1 state , is good.
Step49: Press "Button 1" in C, watch A LED1 state, is no good.
Step50: Press "Button 1" in B, watch A LED1 state, is good.
as "question 002.png" , sorry "Element : 0005" change "Element : 0006".

How do I get A's Subscribe to receive all the Publish?

[Mttrinh]

Hi,

Have you had any progress with this issue? I'm still trying to figuring out what is causing this issue. Didn't manage to do step41, but everything else seems to be the same over here.

[Rex1979]

Hi Mttrinh,

This issue had solve, 
remove “is_valid_source()”,
but have produce new issue.

New issue is simple_on_off_client_set  in client, that can't receive from not slef publish's info,
And simple_on_off_client_set's ack no have go by is_valid_source() , As shown below:

is "question 003.png" ,  is "question 004.png".

[Mttrinh]

Hi,

I'm not sure what the question is. It seems like the picture you attached is similar to what you posted earlier.